We’re Paying Too Much for New Schools

Following below is cost comparison information for school replacement construction.  All of the figures were obtained from the Virginia Beach City Public Schools website, and the Virginia Department of Education website.  It contains all of the relevant state averages going back to the 2014-2015 school year.

As you can see, we are consistently spending more per pupil and per square foot for our new schools than the state average — in some cases about twice as much or more!   Clearly we should be demanding cost savings.  Those dollars could have gone to teacher salaries, school safety, or a property tax reduction.

_________________________________________________


Kellam High School:

Original Building Opened: September 1962
Groundbreaking: September 30, 2011
Construction Start Date/Site Work: Winter 2010/11
Construction Start Date/Building: Summer 2011
Projected Completion: Spring 2014
Student Capacity: 2000
Current Student Membership: 1838
Building Size: 336,410 sq. ft. (two stories)
Total CIP Project Cost: $102 million
Architect: HBA Architecture
Site Contractor: A&W Contractors, Inc.
General Contractor: S.B. Ballard Construction Co.
Cost per pupil:  $55,495.10
Cost per s.f.:  $303.20
Compare:
New high schools 2017-2018 (none)
New high schools 2016-2017
Loudoun County HS
Cost per pupil:  $46,945.00
Cost per s.f.:  $289.92
Note:
Loudoun County Median Household Income:  $134,464 (#1 in US in 2016) (source: U.S. Census Bureau)
Virginia Beach Median Household Income:  $61,805 (source: U.S. Census Bureau)
New high schools 2015-2016 (none)
New high schools 2014-2015
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $35,690
Statewide average cost per s.f. $175.65
___________________________________________________
Old Donation School (Brickell Academy):

Original Building Opened:
Old Donation Center (ODC) – 1965
Kemps Landing Magnet School (KLMS) – 1957
Design Start Date: November 2011
Construction Start Date: Summer 2014
Projected Completion Date: Fall 2017
Student Capacity: 1,375
(ODC-450; KLMS-750; Pullout Programs-175)
Building Size: 225,785 sq. ft. (two – three stories)
Total CIP Project Cost: $63,615,000(+)
Architect: RRMM Architects
Contractor: McKenzie Construction Corporation
Cost per pupil:  $46,265.45*
Cost per s.f.:  $281.75
Compare:
Campostella K-8 STEM School (Norfolk), 2015-2016
Cost per pupil:  $25,919
Cost per s.f.:  $148.86
Also compare with middle school and elementary school averages following below.
___________________________________________________
Thoroughgood ES:
Original Building Opened: 1958
Groundbreaking: TBD
Construction Start Date: 2018
Projected Completion: 2020
New Building Capacity: 648
Current Student Membership: 677
Existing Building Size: 66,259 sq. ft.
New Building Size: approx. 94,000 sq. ft.
Total CIP Project Cost: $28.3 million
Architect: VIA Design Architects
General Contractor: TBD
Cost per pupil:  $41,802
Cost per s.f.:  $301.06
Compare:
New elementary schools 2017-2018
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $29,172
Statewide average cost per s.f. $199.50
New elementary schools 2016-2017
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $26,319
Statewide average cost per s.f. $158.34
New elementary schools 2015-2016
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $22,025
Statewide average cost per s.f. $169.46
Richard H. Bowling Jr. ES  (Norfolk), 2015-2016
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $23,555
Statewide average cost per s.f. $157.32
Ocean View ES (Norfolk), 2015-2016
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $23,066
Statewide average cost per s.f. $168.80
Larchmont ES (Norfolk), 2015-2016
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $24,479
Statewide average cost per s.f. $170.77
New elementary schools 2014-2015
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $25,035
Statewide average cost per s.f. $185.27
___________________________________________________
Princess Anne MS:
Original Building Opened: 1974
Existing Building Demolition: Summer/Fall 2017
Groundbreaking: TBD
Construction Start Date: 2018
Projected Completion: 2021
New Building Capacity: 1,500
Current Student Membership: 1,479
New Building Size: 222,571 sq. ft.
Total CIP Project Cost: $78.9 million
Architect: RRMM Architects
Demolition Contractor: R. J. Smith Construction Inc.
General Contractor: TBD
Cost per pupil: $53,346.86
Cost per s.f.:  $354.49
Compare:
New middle schools 2016-2017
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $36,384
Statewide average cost per s.f. $201.45
New middle schools 2015-2016
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $36,256
Statewide average cost per s.f. $198.11
New middle schools 2014-2015
Statewide average cost per pupil:  $40,121
Statewide average cost per s.f. $179.12
___________________________________________________
(+) This total contains cost of the site as well.
*Cost per pupil is based on current student membership, if available; otherwise, building capacity is used.
**Cost comparison data is from the Virginia Department of Education:

 

Leave a Reply